Genuine Futures responds to the Milburn Review: what would change for young people in Bolton?

Posted on: 18 November 2026 | 6 min

Genuine Futures CIC · 18 November 2026

For Sam Smith, Alan Milburn’s review of youth employment raises a question rooted in his own experience. Why do we wait until young people are in crisis before offering help? Sam, our founder and co-director, was permanently excluded from school, placed in a secure unit at 13 and entered youth custody at 14. More than four decades later, he still sees young people facing barriers he recognises.

“This is 40 years of failure. I was excluded from school, placed in a secure unit at 13 and entered youth custody at 14. That was over 40 years ago, yet we’re still talking about young people falling through the cracks.

If we know which children and young people are struggling, why are we waiting until they’re in crisis before we act?

We need to stop defining young people by what they’ve experienced and start investing in what they can become. The problem isn’t a lack of potential. It’s a lack of opportunity.”

Around one million 16–24-year-olds are out of education, employment or training, often described as NEET. Behind that figure are young people dealing with overlapping challenges, from poor mental health and poverty to repeated rejection when they apply for their first job. The independent Milburn Review, published on 17 November 2026, calls for earlier help and better coordination between services. We welcome that direction. In Bolton, we see three ways it could make a difference: support that starts earlier, trusted relationships and more opportunities to learn through practical work. Read the independent Milburn Review.

What earlier support could look like in Bolton

The Government plans to begin rolling out locally led youth services in 2027. The proposed Youth Opportunity Service would bring together employment, skills and health support and serve as the main route into help for 18–24-year-olds who are out of education or work or at serious risk of becoming NEET. Alongside it, the Government has announced an Opportunity and Support Guarantee covering routes into education, training, apprenticeships, work experience or employment, and a Youth Opportunities Unit to coordinate work across government. Details of local delivery, funding and commissioning are still to come. Read the Government’s announcement.

Those details matter. A young person who has had difficult experiences at school or with formal services may feel more comfortable talking to someone they already know through a local organisation. A trusted mentor can help them think through their options and take a first step, whether that means returning to education, trying a supported placement or building confidence through a practical project.

As Genuine Futures co-director Mike Alleyne puts it:

“We cannot keep waiting until young people have disengaged from education, employment and their communities before offering meaningful support.

Prevention means building trusted relationships early, listening to young people and providing practical opportunities that help them move forward.

The new Youth Opportunity Service must work with organisations that already have those relationships. We need long-term commitment, not another short-term solution.”

An early conversation can make a difference while a young person is still connected to school or college. It can also help the adults around them understand what’s getting in the way, from difficulties attending regularly to additional support needs. The new service should build on the relationships that schools, colleges and community organisations already have with young people and families.

Give young people a first chance to build experience

Megan’s father described a problem familiar to many families: employers want experience, and getting that first opportunity can feel impossible.

“No experience anywhere, can’t get anything. No replies from some places. Just keeps applying and applying, and no response, no nothing.”

Asked whether he’d noticed a difference since Megan joined Genuine Futures, he said, “Oh, massively.” For families, signs of progress can include getting out of the house, spending time with others and gaining the confidence to try something new. Those steps can help a young person work towards education, training or employment.

At Genuine Futures, our Boss Your Future programme combines mentoring, personal development and enterprise education to help young people recognise their strengths and decide what they want to do next. Through We Shine Any Car, they can learn vehicle valeting while working as a team, dealing with customers and taking responsibility for a job. Our developing partnership with Bolton Wanderers gives young people experience in a professional environment. Through Live Local, Trust Local, they can explore digital marketing, video production and entrepreneurship while supporting local businesses.

These programmes show why we want enterprise education to have a clear place in the Youth Opportunity Service. Helping with a customer enquiry, producing a video for a local business or working out what it costs to deliver a service gives young people a chance to practise skills they can use in a job or in a business of their own.

As one Genuine Futures youth voice representative told us:

“Sometimes you just need someone to give you a chance. It’s hard to build experience when nobody will give you your first opportunity. Being involved in something practical helps you build confidence and see what you can achieve.”

What we’re asking the Government to do

The Bolton NEET Taskforce starts with listening to young people about what gets in their way and what would help. It brings them together with employers, community organisations and local partners to identify gaps in support and create more practical opportunities.

One professional partner described the challenge this way:

“The challenge isn’t simply identifying young people who need support. It’s making sure the right opportunities are available when they’re ready to engage. Strong partnerships between education, employers and community organisations can make that transition much more achievable.”

We want the new service to act early when young people begin to disengage and give young people and people with lived experience an ongoing role in designing and evaluating support. Enterprise should sit alongside education and employment as a recognised pathway. Trusted local organisations need accessible commissioning and longer-term funding so they have time to build relationships and deliver consistently.

The service should also measure what happens after a referral. Did the young person gain skills and confidence? Did they stay in education, training or work? Did their wellbeing improve? Those outcomes would show whether the support is helping young people make progress that lasts.

Help us create more opportunities in Bolton

Genuine Futures wants to work with Bolton Council, Greater Manchester Combined Authority, Jobcentre Plus, schools, colleges, employers, health services and community organisations to shape how the new service could work locally. A workplace visit, a supported placement or a practical project can give a young person their first look at an industry they might never have considered.

If your organisation can offer work experience, mentoring, employment, funding or specialist expertise, we’d like to hear from you. Email sam@genuinefutures.co.uk or visit the Genuine Futures website.

What the review means for young people.

I need help